The Somerton Man Video Archive: Evidence & Analysis
Below is a curated selection of videos detailing key aspects of the Somerton Man investigation, code breaking, and Cold War connections. For the benefit of researchers, each video is accompanied by a readable narrative transcript.
1. Sir David Omand: The Four Pillars of Intelligence Analysis
Former GCHQ Director Sir David Omand outlines the "SEES" methodology used by intelligence officers to evaluate evidence and avoid deception—critical skills for analyzing the Somerton Man case.
▼ Click here to read the Transcript / Story
In this lecture, Sir David Omand, the former director of GCHQ, breaks down the methodology used by intelligence officers to make solid, evidence-based decisions. He introduces the acronym SEES, representing the four distinct types of information required for high-level decision-making.
1. Situational Awareness (S)
The first step is understanding what is actually happening on the ground or in cyberspace. This answers the factual questions of "what, when, and where." Omand warns that our knowledge of the world is always incomplete, fragmentary, and sometimes wrong. One must be wary of the "filter bubble" and deliberate deception. Facts alone, however, mean nothing without an explanation.
2. Explanation (E)
This addresses the "why and how." Omand uses the analogy of a man accused of throwing a bottle at a policeman; the forensic fact (fingerprints on the bottle) is identical, but the explanation (he threw it vs. he put it in a recycling bin and the mob picked it up) changes everything. A common trap is jumping from facts directly to predictions without a grounded explanation. One must test explanations against data, choosing the one with the least evidence against it, rather than looking for evidence to support a favorite theory.
3. Estimation (E)
This involves modeling how events might unfold based on your explanation. Omand cites the COVID-19 pandemic, where estimates of hospital impact depended crucially on assumptions about public compliance with mask-wearing. This is often an art rather than a science, using Bayesian inference to estimate possible outcomes.
4. Strategic Notice (S)
The final pillar is the ability to handle the unexpected. Strategic notice is not about projecting the past forward, but using imagination to look into the future and work backward. For example, if China were to develop a workable quantum computer, they could read the world's encrypted communications. Strategic notice asks: "If that were to happen, what should we do now?" This allows agencies to prepare for a range of possible outcomes, ensuring they are not surprised by surprise itself.
2. Richard Moore (C): The Modern Landscape of MI6
A rare insight into the mindset of "C" (the Chief of MI6), discussing recruitment, the ethics of espionage, and the modern threats from Russia and China.
▼ Click here to read the Transcript / Story
The State of the World
Former MI6 Chief Richard Moore reflects on his five years leading the agency, describing the current international environment as "extraordinarily contested." He notes that the established diplomatic "tram lines" that managed global relations after 1945 are no longer firmly in place. He highlights the breakdown in relationships between leading powers, particularly following Russian aggression in Ukraine and the complex dynamic between Washington and Beijing.
China: Opportunity and Threat
Moore discusses the duality of China as the major intelligence challenge of the 21st century. He explains that intelligence agencies do not just manage threats but also gather intelligence to help political leaders seize opportunities. However, he is clear that China is intent on gathering intelligence against the UK and engaging in activities that threaten British interests. He argues for a "robust" approach, noting that Beijing respects strength and that standing up for values often does not negatively impact trade as feared.
Recruitment and "The Tap on the Shoulder"
Moore recounts his own recruitment in the early 1980s, admitting he is a "stereotypical example" of the old "tap on the shoulder" at Oxford University. An academic suggested he consider an "alternative career" in foreign affairs. While this method has been abandoned for more open recruitment today, Moore reflects on the unique psychological demands of the job: the need for secrecy, the inability to seek public recognition, and the moral complexity of forging intimate relationships with agents to obtain secrets.
The Ethics of Espionage
Moore addresses the moral dilemmas inherent in spying. He emphasizes that intelligence officers must be "centered individuals" with low egos to navigate ethical gray areas without losing their moral compass. He firmly defends the modern ethos of the service regarding the treatment of detainees, stating that while mistakes were made in the past (referencing the post-9/11 era), strict compliance processes are now in place.
Ukraine and Russia
On the subject of the war in Ukraine, Moore states that intelligence indicates Vladimir Putin has no intention of making a peace deal and is focused on domination. Moore argues that the only way to end the conflict is to put Putin under sufficient pressure—military and economic—to force a change in calculation. He stresses the importance of the Western alliance not losing this "contest of wills," as both Putin and President Xi of China are watching closely for signs of weakness.
3. Tim Tate on Peter Wright & The Spycatcher Scandal
The story of Peter Wright, the scientist and counter-espionage officer who accused MI5 Director Roger Hollis of being a Soviet mole, leading to the infamous "Spycatcher" trial.
▼ Click here to read the Transcript / Story
The Man Behind the Book
Investigative journalist Tim Tate discusses Peter Wright, the controversial author of Spycatcher. For 20 years, Wright was MI5’s most senior counter-espionage officer, a self-taught scientist and "boffin" who revolutionized the agency's surveillance technology. However, Wright became convinced that the British establishment was "rotten to the core" with Soviet penetration. Tate describes Wright as a complex figure: a brilliant scientist and a loving family man, but also a prickly character with a deep resentment for the "shiny-bottomed" university graduates who ran the civil service.
The Roger Hollis Investigation
The core of Wright’s obsession was Sir Roger Hollis, the Director General of MI5, whom Wright suspected of being a Soviet mole. Tate reveals that despite Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher’s public statement clearing Hollis, declassified documents from 2023 show the government’s own internal inquiry (the Trend Report) concluded there was a "20% chance" Hollis was indeed a spy. Wright believed that in counter-intelligence, the country should get the benefit of the doubt, not the individual.
When Wright attempted to publish Spycatcher from his retirement in Tasmania, the British government launched a disastrous legal battle to silence him. They argued that Intelligence Officers owed a lifelong duty of silence. Tate describes the trial as descending into farce, with the government admitting facts in an Australian court while denouncing them as lies in the British Parliament.
The Streisand Effect & Legacy
The government’s attempt to ban the book backfired spectacularly. Instead of selling a projected 20,000 copies, Spycatcher sold over 4 million copies worldwide. Ironically, the scandal achieved the exact opposite of what Thatcher intended. The public outcry and the absurdity of the trial forced the government to finally place MI5, MI6, and GCHQ on a legal statutory footing with parliamentary oversight—something that had never existed before the affair.
Hi
Welcome to the Tamam Shud Blog, widely regarded as the leading and most trusted fact and evidence-based blog on the Somerton Man case. We do not collect your login or address details